Potbelly Sandwich Menu: Fresh & Toasted Subs To Go

Looking for a tasty toasted sandwich that’s different? Potbelly Sandwich Works offers a delicious experience that changes your lunch game. They’ve been making fresh, toasted sandwiches for over 40 years.

Potbelly has over 425 shops in the United States. They’re experts at making tasty sandwiches. Their menu has everything from classic subs to new flavors.

They have a wide variety of menu items to satisfy your hunger and taste. Whether you need a quick lunch or a big dinner, their sandwiches are perfect. They’re more than just fast food.

Potbelly Menu Prices Overview

The History of Potbelly: From Antique Shop to Sandwich Empire

Potbelly’s journey started in Chicago, turning from an antique store to a favorite sandwich spot. This story shows how passion and creativity can change the game in the food world.

Origins in Chicago 1977

In 1977, a small antique shop in Chicago became the start of something big. The owners began serving sandwiches, and soon found out people loved their food more than antiques.

• Began as a small antique store in Chicago
• Started serving sandwiches to customers
• Sandwiches quickly became more popular than antiques

Evolution into a National Chain

The idea of serving tasty, toasted sandwiches quickly gained fans. Starting as a local spot, Potbelly grew across the U.S. It drew in food enthusiasts with its unique sandwich-making style.

The Signature Toasting Process

Potbelly’s focus on flavor made them stand out. Their toasting method is key, making sandwiches warm and crispy. It’s a big reason why people keep coming back.

Year	Milestone
1977	First store opens in Chicago
1990s	Transition from antique shop to sandwich restaurant
2000s	Expansion across multiple states

Exploring the Potbelly Sandwich Menu

Potbelly Sandwich Shop offers a wide range of lunch options. Their menu has many deli-style sandwiches. These are made to fill your hunger and please your taste buds.

Their sandwiches take you on a flavor journey. You can find many types of sandwiches to suit every taste:

• Hot toasted submarines
• Classic cold deli-style sandwiches
• Specialty meat combinations
• Vegetarian sandwich selections

Every sandwich is made with top-notch ingredients. Potbelly’s special toasting method adds to the flavor. Their menu has both classic and new sandwiches to try.

Cheese is a big part of Potbelly’s sandwiches. They have many cheese options, including:

• Cheddar
• Swiss
• Provolone
• Blue cheese
• Feta

Their toasting method makes the cheese extra tasty. You can also customize your sandwich to your liking. This makes lunch both fun and tasty.

Signature Hot Submarines and Specialties

Potbelly Sandwich Works offers a wide range of hot submarine sandwiches. These sandwiches turn simple menu items into something special. Their flatbread sandwiches are a mix of fresh ingredients and perfectly toasted.

A Wreck – The Famous Multi-Meat Sandwich

The “A Wreck” sandwich is a dream for meat lovers. It has layers of different meats, making it a filling meal. Potbelly’s chefs put together salami, roast beef, turkey, and ham for a unique taste.

Mediterranean Style Options

Potbelly also has Mediterranean-inspired flatbread sandwiches. These sandwiches are light but full of flavor. You can try:

• Mediterranean veggie sandwich
• Hummus-based protein options
• Grilled vegetable selections

Meatball and Italian Specialties

Italian food lovers will enjoy Potbelly’s Italian-style sandwiches. The meatball submarine is a favorite, with:

1. Handcrafted meatballs
2. Robust marinara sauce
3. Melted provolone cheese

Fresh Cold Sandwiches Selection

Potbelly Sandwich Shop offers a delightful array of cold sandwiches. These are perfect for those looking for fresh and satisfying meals. They are a cool alternative to the restaurant’s signature grilled options.

The cold sandwiches show Potbelly’s commitment to quality. They offer customizable lunch options. Diners can find fresh combinations of premium meats and crisp vegetables.

• Classic turkey and ham options
• Vegetarian-friendly selections
• Premium meat and cheese combinations

Potbelly’s cold sandwiches feature five cheese varieties. These enhance the flavor profiles:

Each sandwich is made with fresh-sliced meats and cheeses. This ensures a high-quality lunch experience. Customers can customize their sandwiches with different bread types and fresh vegetables.

The cold sandwich selection is great for health-conscious diners. They offer delicious sandwiches without the grilled preparation. With many protein and vegetable options, there’s something for everyone.

Premium Cheese Options and Melts

Potbelly Sandwich Shop is proud of its wide range of cheeses. These cheeses make any sandwich a gourmet delight. Cheese fans will love the variety that turns simple sandwiches into something special.

Variety of Cheese Selections

Potbelly has a big selection of cheeses for everyone. Their cheeses include:

• Cheddar – A classic, sharp flavor
• Swiss – Mild and nutty profile
• Provolone – Smooth and creamy texture
• Blue cheese – Bold and tangy option
• Feta – Crumbly Mediterranean style cheese

Special Cheese Combinations

For those who love unique cheese pairings, Potbelly has something special. Each mix is made to boost the sandwich’s flavor.

Grilled Cheese Variations

Potbelly’s grilled cheese is the ultimate comfort food. The classic version has melted cheddar on toasted bread. It’s a golden-brown delight that hits the spot every time.

Salads and Healthy Alternatives

Potbelly Sandwich Shop knows people want healthier lunch choices. They offer fresh, tasty salads as a healthy alternative to sandwiches.

Looking for a healthy meal? Potbelly has a wide range of salads. You can choose from different proteins and add your favorite ingredients. This way, you can make a lunch that’s just right for you.

• Fresh mixed greens as base options
• Protein-rich toppings including grilled chicken and turkey
• Vegetarian and plant-based selections
• Low-calorie dressing choices

Potbelly uses only the best ingredients in their salads. They choose locally grown produce and high-quality proteins. This ensures every salad is full of flavor and good for you.

Salad Nutrition Highlights

Salad Type	Protein	Calories
Mediterranean Salad	Grilled Chicken	320
Classic Garden Salad	Mixed Greens	220
Protein Power Salad	Turkey	380

Millennials and Generation Z love Potbelly’s healthy lunch options. They offer salads that you can customize to fit your diet. This makes it easy to find a meal that’s just right for you.

Sides and Accompaniments

Potbelly knows that amazing sandwiches need great sides. Their menu has a wide range of sides that make any meal special. These sides turn a simple meal into a memorable one.

Creamy Mac & Cheese Delight

The famous mac & cheese is a favorite among Potbelly’s sides. It’s made with creamy cheese and al dente pasta. This comfort food is the perfect match for any sandwich.

• Creamy texture that melts in your mouth
• Made with premium cheese blend
• Served hot and fresh

Hearty Soup Selection

Potbelly’s soups are warm and nutritious. They offer a variety of flavors, from classic tomato to seasonal specials. These soups are a tasty choice for a lighter side.

Premium Chips for the Perfect Crunch

No sandwich is complete without the right crunch. Potbelly’s premium chips offer a crispy texture and bold flavors. They perfectly complement their signature sandwiches.

Side Item	Description	Price
Mac & Cheese	Creamy cheese pasta	$3.99
Soup of the Day	Rotating seasonal options	$4.49
Premium Chips	Assorted flavors	$1.99

These carefully chosen sides make every Potbelly meal complete. They offer something delicious for everyone.

Sweet Treats and Desserts

Potbelly’s restaurant menus are a hit with their tasty desserts. Fresh-baked cookies and sweet treats are the perfect end to any meal. They delight customers with homemade flavors and quality ingredients.

The menu offers a range of irresistible cookie options. You can choose from classic flavors or seasonal specialties. This keeps the dessert selection exciting and fresh.

• Classic Chocolate Chip Cookie
• Toffee Butter Brickle Cookie
• Seasonal Limited-Edition Cookies

On special occasions like Valentine’s Day, Potbelly has unique treats for Perks Members. The Red Velvet Cookie, available with any entrée purchase, shows their dedication to memorable dining experiences.

Looking for a sweet finish to your sandwich or a quick treat? Potbelly’s dessert menu has delightful options for every sweet tooth.

Beverage Selection and Signature Shakes

Potbelly restaurant menus offer a delightful range of refreshing beverages. They have hand-dipped milkshakes and hot and cold drinks. There’s something for every thirst.

Hand-Dipped Milkshake Flavors

Potbelly’s signature milkshakes are known for their rich, creamy texture and unique flavors. Customers can enjoy a variety of mouth-watering options:

• Vanilla Shake ($6.69, 698 calories)
• Chocolate Shake ($6.69, 773 calories)
• Strawberry Shake ($6.69, 745 calories)
• Toasted Marshmallow Shake ($7.09, 760 calories)
• OREO® Cookie Shake ($7.09, 769 calories)
• Cold Brew Shake ($7.09, 770 calories)
• American Apple Pie Shake ($7.09, 730 calories)

Hot and Cold Drink Options

Potbelly’s menus go beyond milkshakes. They offer a wide range of beverages for every taste.

Potbelly ensures customers can find the perfect drink to go with their meal. With such a wide array of menu items, everyone can find something they like.

Catering and Group Order Options

Potbelly Sandwich Works knows how important it is to have easy group dining. Their catering services offer tasty sandwiches and menu items great for corporate events, parties, and big gatherings.

Catering options make meal planning for groups easy. Customers can pick from many sandwich platters and boxed lunch combos. These choices fit different diets and group sizes.

Catering Package Highlights

• Sandwich platters with many meat and vegetarian options
• Boxed individual lunches
• Large group meal packages
• Customizable menu selections

Group Order Advantages

Potbelly uses tech to make catering easier. They work with platforms like ezCater. This helps them serve over 100,000 restaurants across the country, making group meal ordering smooth and accurate.

Catering Feature	Details
Average Order Value	$400+
Order Platforms	ezCater, Direct Ordering
Menu Customization	Flexible Options

Planning a small team lunch or a big corporate event? Potbelly’s catering services offer tasty sandwiches with ease and quality.

Pick-Your-Pair Combinations and Value Meals

Potbelly has changed lunch with its Pick-Your-Pair menu. Now, you can mix and match smaller portions of different dishes. This way, you get a meal that’s both tasty and affordable.

The Pick-Your-Pair lets you try different foods without spending too much. It’s perfect for those who want to taste a variety of flavors without breaking the bank.

Combination Highlights

• Half sandwich + half salad
• Small soup + half sandwich
• Chips + half sandwich
• Half salad + small soup

Value Meal Pricing Strategy

Combination Type	Typical Price Range	Calories
Half Sandwich + Soup	$7.50 – $9.00	350-500
Half Sandwich + Salad	$8.00 – $9.50	400-550
Soup + Chips	$6.50 – $7.50	250-400

Potbelly is growing with 38 new shops planned for 2025. They’re also adding more to their menu. The Pick-Your-Pair shows their focus on flexible, affordable meals for everyone.

Conclusion

Potbelly Sandwich Shop is a standout in the crowded restaurant world. They offer a unique dining experience. Their focus on fresh ingredients and diverse sandwiches makes them different.

Their menu has something for everyone. From the famous A Wreck to vegetarian options, there’s a lot to choose from. You can pick from cheddar, Swiss, or blue cheese to make your meal just right.

Looking for a hot submarine, a fresh salad, or creamy mac & cheese? Potbelly has it all. They make every sandwich a special experience, making people come back for more.

For a tasty lunch or dinner, Potbelly’s menu is a great choice. Check out a location near you. See why so many love their sandwiches in the United States.

FAQ

What are the most popular sandwiches at Potbelly?

The A Wreck is Potbelly’s top sandwich, with salami, ham, turkey, and roast beef. The Mediterranean and meatball subs are also favorites. They show off Potbelly’s toasted sandwich style.

Does Potbelly offer vegetarian or gluten-free options?

Yes, Potbelly has vegetarian options like the Mediterranean. They also offer gluten-free bread for many sandwiches. You can customize salads and choose from various vegetable-based options.

How can I order Potbelly for catering or large groups?

Potbelly has catering packages for all group sizes and diets. You can order online or call your local Potbelly for corporate events, parties, or meetings.

Are nutrition details available for Potbelly menu items?

Yes, Potbelly lists nutrition info for all menu items online and in-store. You can find calorie counts, ingredient lists, and allergen info to make healthy choices.

Can I customize my sandwich at Potbelly?

Absolutely! You can customize your sandwich at Potbelly. Choose your bread, meats, cheeses, toppings, and whether it’s toasted or not.

Do they offer any loyalty or rewards programs?

Yes, Potbelly has a mobile app with a rewards program. You earn points for purchases, get special offers, and discounts. Redeem points for free menu items and perks.